- Every supplement should have a clear purpose: treating an underlying problem, correcting a deficiency, or relieving symptoms in a way that helps you function.
- “Natural” doesn’t mean harmless. Supplements can cause side effects, interact with medications, and duplicate ingredients.
- Methylated B vitamins deserve the same thoughtful review as everything else on your list.
- Simplify gradually, one change at a time, and with your clinician.
It usually starts with a good reason.
Something for sleep. Something for digestion. A recommendation from a friend who swears it changed her life. Then a podcast, a lab result, or another symptom leads to another bottle.
Before long, you’re taking a handful of supplements several times a day—and you’re still not feeling well.
When a new patient brings a long supplement list to our first visit, one of my first questions is:
Which of these do you know makes a difference in how you feel?
Dr. Teresa Birkmeier-FredalOften, there are a few clear answers, and those are useful observations. Then there’s the rest of the list.
What I usually hear
The clear answers
- “This helps me sleep.”
- “My constipation comes back without that.”
The rest of the list
- “I heard this was good for inflammation.”
- “This is supposed to support my mitochondria.”
- “I’m honestly not sure why I’m still taking that one.”
That’s where we start looking more closely.
A good explanation isn’t the same as a good result
A supplement can have an impressive description and a plausible mechanism without making a meaningful difference for you.
I generally take a less-is-more approach. I want medications and supplements to have a clear purpose: treating an underlying problem, correcting a deficiency, or providing symptom relief that actually helps you function.
Every product should earn its place
Treat an underlying problem
It addresses something that is driving your symptoms.
Correct a deficiency
It replaces something your body is actually missing.
Relieve symptoms
It reliably helps you sleep, eat, or get through your day.
Symptom relief matters. If something reliably helps you sleep, eat, or get through your day, that deserves consideration. But adding another product for every symptom can leave you with a complicated routine while the underlying problem remains unaddressed.
Before adding something new, ask: What are we treating, and how will we know whether this is helping?
Supplements can become part of the problem
We tend to give supplements the benefit of the doubt. They’re vitamins, herbs, or “natural” products, so it’s easy to assume they can’t hurt.
But supplements can cause side effects, interact with medications, and duplicate ingredients you’re already getting elsewhere. Taking several products together can also make it difficult to recognize which one is causing trouble.
“Natural” isn’t the same as harmless
Side effects
Vitamins, herbs, and other products can cause reactions of their own.
Interactions
Supplements can interact with the medications you take.
Duplicate ingredients
You may already be getting the same ingredient elsewhere.
Hidden culprits
With several products at once, it’s hard to tell which one is causing trouble.
This is especially relevant when someone has mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), histamine-related symptoms, or ongoing digestive problems such as IBS or reflux. When symptoms fluctuate and several products are being taken at once, it can be hard to tell whether a new supplement is helping, doing nothing, or making things worse.
Your friend may feel wonderful taking something that leaves you feeling miserable. Both experiences can be real.
Permission to let go
You don’t have to keep taking a supplement simply because it’s supposed to be good for you.
A word about methylated B vitamins
B vitamins deserve the same thoughtful review as everything else on your list.
I’m particularly cautious about automatically adding methylated B vitamins in patients with persistent symptoms after COVID, especially when MCAS or significant sensitivities are part of the picture. If you’ve felt worse after starting methylfolate, methyl B12, a B complex, or a multivitamin, that timing deserves attention. (I explore this further in Post-COVID B Vitamin Intolerance.)
Feeling worse, however, does not by itself prove that a supplement has increased inflammation or glutamate. Those mechanisms have not been established as a general effect of methylated B vitamins in people with long COVID or MCAS.
The practical point is simpler: your body needs adequate B vitamins, but that doesn’t mean you automatically need a high-dose supplement—or that every form and dose will suit you. A documented deficiency still needs treatment. The choice of product should reflect your needs and your response, rather than the assumption that everyone should take the same multivitamin.
Not sure what on your list is actually helping? Let’s review it together.
Call (248) 289-6349How we begin simplifying
I ask patients to separate the supplements they clearly benefit from from the ones they take because “these are supposed to help.”
For each product, we work through a few questions:
Five questions for every bottle
Why did you start it?
What changed after you started taking it?
If you’ve missed it or stopped it before, did you notice a difference?
Is there a lab result or another medical reason to continue it, even if you don’t feel an immediate benefit?
Does it still fit what we’re treating now?
That last point matters. Something that was useful six months ago may no longer be necessary.
We usually peel away the uncertain additions gradually, making one change at a time so the response is easier to interpret. This should be done with your clinician, particularly when a supplement was prescribed for a deficiency or another specific medical need. There’s no need to deliberately restart something that caused a significant reaction just to prove it was responsible.
The goal is to find out what belongs in your plan.
You’re allowed to have a simpler routine
People who are chronically ill often work incredibly hard to get better. Researching, ordering, organizing, timing, and paying for supplements can become a job of its own.
Letting go of a bottle can feel like letting go of a chance to improve. I understand that.
But keeping something indefinitely out of fear that it might be helping has a cost, too—in money, effort, and sometimes how you feel.
I would rather see a patient taking a short, purposeful list that moves their health forward than a long list they’re afraid to change.
The rule of thumb
Every supplement should have a reason to stay. “It’s supposed to help” is a reason to evaluate it—not a reason to take it forever.
Restorative Medicine Center
A Shorter List With a Clear Purpose
We help you sort out what is truly helping, address the root causes behind your symptoms, and build a plan you can sustain.

